Surah Al-Kahf — Reflections
Juz 15 | Introduction to the Surah
1. The Historical Background — Three Questions
I want to begin Surah Al-Kahf with the well-known narration of the Mushrikeen of Makkah approaching the Jewish scholars of Madinah to test the prophethood of Muhammad ﷺ.
The Jewish scholars gave them three questions: about the young men of the cave, the person who travelled to the east and west, and the Ruh.
What particularly catches my attention is the ambiguity of their language. If the Prophet ﷺ could not answer, Quraysh were told to form their own judgment and deal with him as they thought appropriate. They did not explicitly say, kill him. They left the decision to the Mushrikeen. Was this not a politically convenient position? If anything happened to the Prophet ﷺ, they could always distance themselves from the consequences: We never instructed you to do that.
Whether this was actually their intention cannot be established from the narration. But the wording itself makes me reflect on how religious knowledge, authority, and political interests can become entangled. This narration, preserved in the early Sirah literature, will be our first introduction to Surah Al-Kahf.
2. Religious Authority, Its Corruption, and the Intellectual Revolt
From here, I want to walk back into Christian history.
Christianity itself experienced persecution under Roman authority. Later, when Christianity acquired imperial support, religious institutions gradually gained enormous authority and power.
The Church became not merely a religious institution but, in many periods and places, a powerful political and social authority. And what happens when religious authority becomes corrupted?
Cruelty. Suppression of questioning. Diminishing realities. Forcing people to accept interpretations without allowing reasoning or independent examination. When religion is presented through coercion, when religious institutions become more concerned with preserving their authority than allowing people to seek truth, the human response can eventually become rebellion.
The Protestant Reformation emerged as a protest against aspects of Church authority and practice. It was itself a religious movement, but the broader historical changes that followed contributed to a very different intellectual world.
My concern is how humanity, while trying to free itself from oppressive religious authority, gradually moved in some intellectual traditions toward the other extreme: questioning the relevance of religion itself. God, the soul, the Hereafter, and belief in a higher authority had been part of human civilizations in different forms.
Whether Christianity, Hinduism, Zoroastrianism, or Greek mythology, civilizations generally recognized some power or reality greater than the individual human being, although their beliefs about that power differed enormously. Then a different worldview increasingly gained influence.
Thinkers such as Nietzsche challenged the traditional foundations of religious morality. His ideas about power and the death of God questioned the place of divine authority in modern human life. Marx interpreted religion through social and economic relations. Darwin's theory changed the scientific understanding of life and its development. These thinkers were not advancing one identical philosophy, nor were they all products of Protestantism. But their ideas became part of a wider transformation in how human beings understood themselves and the world.
What troubles me is the direction taken by materialist thinking.
The Three Great Replacements — God, Soul and Hereafter
A gradual shift in human thinking has changed the very foundations upon which we understand life and reality. What was once understood through God, the soul, and the Hereafter is increasingly interpreted through the universe, the body, and this worldly life.
1. The Great God Replaced by the Great Universe
God is Great, but unseen. The universe is also great—vast, magnificent, observable, and seemingly limitless. Why not turn our attention towards this Great Universe instead?
Galaxies, stars, planets, cosmic forces, and the mysteries of space inspire awe. The more we explore, the more we realize how little we know. But in materialist thinking, the universe itself increasingly becomes the ultimate reality. The question shifts from Who created this universe? to How does this universe work? The Creator is pushed out of the discussion, while His creation becomes the centre of our admiration, research, and intellectual pursuit.
The Qur'an repeatedly invites us to observe the universe—but as a means of recognizing its Creator. What a shift when we continue studying the signs while no longer asking Whom they point towards.
2. The Soul Replaced by the Body
The same shift takes place in our understanding of human beings. Medicine studies the physical body, while even psychology and mental sciences increasingly explain emotions, behaviour, happiness, suffering, and human responses through hormones, neurotransmitters, chemical imbalances, and neurological processes.
Sadness, anxiety, love, satisfaction, and pleasure are studied through biological mechanisms—dopamine, serotonin, and other chemical processes. But where is the soul? Where is the Qalb that the Qur'an repeatedly addresses?
The problem is not the scientific understanding of the body or brain. It is reducing the whole human being to these material explanations, as though nothing exists beyond what can be observed and measured. The Ruh is gradually being squeezed out of our understanding of human existence, leaving behind a body to be studied, treated, stimulated, and satisfied.
3. The Hereafter Replaced by This World
And the same transformation extends from individuals to societies. Sociology, civics, economics, urban planning, and technological development increasingly focus on building a better, more comfortable, and more enjoyable worldly life. Metropolitan cities emerge—beautifully planned, technologically advanced, automated, and equipped with every imaginable convenience. Smart cities, intelligent infrastructure, endless entertainment, luxury, comfort, and instant satisfaction. Humanity seems determined to create its own Jannah, right here in this world. A world where every material need is fulfilled, every discomfort minimized, and every desire satisfied.
But where is the Hereafter in this vision of progress? Where is accountability beyond worldly laws? Where is the understanding that this life is temporary and its beauty is only a test?
When the Hereafter disappears from our vision, the purpose of civilization becomes increasingly centred on perfecting this worldly existence, as though it were our final destination.
And how striking that Surah Al-Kahf reminds us:
وَإِنَّا لَجَاعِلُونَ مَا عَلَيْهَا صَعِيدًا جُرُزًا
Everything we are so occupied with beautifying will one day become barren ground. The Great God replaced by the Great Universe. The Soul replaced by the Body. The Hereafter replaced by this World. Three dimensions of the same intellectual shift—where everything is gradually reduced to what is material, visible, measurable, and immediately attainable.
Knowledge continues to expand. Technology advances. Cities become more beautiful. Life becomes more comfortable. But the Ruh is being squeezed out of every concept—out of knowledge, out of human existence, and out of our understanding of life's ultimate purpose. And this is the one-eyed perspective that troubles me: humanity becoming increasingly capable of understanding and controlling the material world, while losing sight of the other dimension of reality.
Of course, science itself continues to confront realities that challenge simplistic explanations. Developments in physics, including Einstein's work, and philosophical questions about consciousness and metaphysics remind us that our understanding remains incomplete.
But the increasingly dominant mentality in many areas of modern life is to invest, produce, consume, and obtain results—right here, in this world.
Religion becomes a private matter, restricted largely to individual belief or personal morals.
Human beings consider themselves sufficiently intellectual and powerful to construct their own moral systems. And from this point onward, the world begins changing at an almost unimaginable speed.
3. The World We Call Free
We cannot even understand one change before another arrives. We are unable to grasp what the future holds for humanity. From materialism to individualism, then consumerism and hyper-consumerism, the world has developed systems that continuously promise satisfaction. But at what cost? We consider ourselves free.
Are we really free?
For producers and marketing systems, we are increasingly objects—targets, consumers, profiles, and data. Nothing seems entirely private anymore. Our interests, habits, likes, dislikes, emotions, and preferences are continuously observed and influenced. The devices in our hands make every one of us vulnerable. Facebook / Instagram shows me advertisements based on my interests. Social media keeps feeding me content similar to what I have already consumed. AI gives me answers in the language and style I prefer. ChatGPT, Claude, and other systems may even reinforce my existing opinions rather than challenge them.
We are living in bubbles. And we think we have freedom! We have become dependent upon societies, producers, devices, likes and dislikes, and the picture-perfect image we want to maintain before the world. This is a different kind of slavery—one that often does not feel like slavery because it comes through convenience, comfort, and personal choice. What disturbs me even more is the gradual disappearance of correction. Everyone thinks they are right. Everyone has access to information. Everyone considers themselves knowledgeable. Nobody wants to be corrected. The experience of elders becomes irrelevant. Family systems lose their influence. Guidance is increasingly interpreted as interference. The idea that nobody should judge anyone, when taken to an extreme, becomes an excuse to escape moral accountability.
This is my life. I can do whatever I want.
But where is the responsibility for our actions? Where is the fear of answering before Allah? We are surrounded by information, yet this does not necessarily mean we possess knowledge or wisdom.
Even the study of human beings increasingly focuses on physical and psychological processes. These are important areas of knowledge, but when human behaviour is explained entirely through dopamine, brain chemistry, or mental processes, where does the Ruh fit? Where is the moral and spiritual dimension?
Iqbal's concern about knowledge without Ruh seems increasingly relevant.
And then there is the colonization of knowledge itself. The growing tendency to recognize only certain forms of knowledge as legitimate, while religious or spiritual perspectives are dismissed as outdated or intellectually inferior.
If you think spiritually, you are outdated. If you are religious, you are outdated. If you are unwilling to consume and compete for more of this world, you are missing your opportunity.
Who knows about the Hereafter?
Why should anyone sacrifice even a little worldly benefit for something beyond this life?
This world gradually becomes the only reality worth pursuing. And alongside this, even definitions of morality and justice appear increasingly dependent upon power. When powerful nations attack weaker ones, their actions can be described as necessary for security, reform, or maintaining order. When weaker people resist, the language changes to extremism or terrorism.
Who gets to define justice? Who decides which violence is legitimate? How do we claim universal moral principles while applying them so selectively? Human beings have gained extraordinary power, yet with all our freedom, we have also become a threat to one another.
4. Dajjal — The Fitnah of Power, Resources, and Deception
This brings me to the authentic narrations concerning Dajjal. Before making any connection with our times, I want to explore the questions:
Who is Dajjal? What extraordinary powers will he possess? And what exactly makes his fitnah so dangerous?
From authentic hadith, we find descriptions of an extraordinary trial. Dajjal will travel across the earth with tremendous speed. Rain, vegetation, food, water, and other material resources will become part of his trial. Those who accept him will experience apparent prosperity, while those who reject him may face deprivation. He will have Kafir written between his eyes. He is described as one-eyed. He will have what appears to be Jannah and Jahannam, but the reality will be reversed. The narrations describe the killing and restoration to life of a young man as part of his extraordinary fitnah.
The very concept of Dajjal is connected with deception—falsehood presented in a way that can confuse human beings about what is true. What interests me is the nature of the fitnah.
Control over resources. Control over prosperity. Control over people's material needs. Extraordinary mobility and power. And, above all, deception.
What more could a person or nation desire in terms of worldly authority? Now look at the world around us.
Economic power increasingly concentrated in the hands of large institutions and producers. Artificial intelligence shaping how people obtain information and make decisions. Personalized digital environments where individuals may never encounter a perspective that seriously challenges their existing beliefs. Knowledge itself increasingly filtered through systems and institutions whose assumptions we may not understand. And the political world, with its continuing wars, competing claims of global authority, and discussions of new world orders.
I am not claiming that these technologies or institutions are literally Dajjal or that a particular modern political development fulfils a prophecy. But the nature of his fitnah makes me examine the world we have created. We are already becoming accustomed to measuring everything through power, resources, material prosperity, and visible results.
And here the one-eyed description of Dajjal makes me reflect upon a one-eyed worldview.
The hadith gives a physical description. But as a reflection, I see a connection with a mentality that looks at reality through only one perspective—the material perspective. One eye sees dunya. But where is the other dimension? Where is the Ruh? Where is the Hereafter? Where is Allah's authority? Where is the accountability that exists beyond courts, governments, markets, and human laws?
The human being has become immensely capable of observing, producing, and controlling material things. But has that made us better at recognizing truth? And how easily truth and falsehood can become mixed when falsehood arrives with everything we desire.
Dajjal's apparent Jannah is actually Jahannam, and his apparent Jahannam is Jannah. This reversal of appearances is frightening. We may see prosperity and assume success. We may see deprivation and assume failure. We may see power and assume truth. But what if reality is entirely different from what appears before our eyes?
5. Surah Al-Kahf — Allah Has Already Given Us a Cave
And now the opening of Surah Al-Kahf.
الْحَمْدُ لِلَّهِ الَّذِي أَنْزَلَ عَلَىٰ عَبْدِهِ الْكِتَابَ وَلَمْ يَجْعَل لَّهُ عِوَجًا ۜ قَيِّمًا
This leaves me in awe. Before Allah tells us the story of Ashab Al-Kahf, He begins with the Qur'an. A Book without crookedness. QAYYIM.
The world is moving from one extreme to another. Religious authority becomes corrupted, and human beings move toward rejecting religious authority itself. Humanity acquires knowledge and begins imagining that it knows everything. It acquires power and begins imagining that it needs no authority greater than itself. Moral standards shift. Definitions change. New philosophies replace older ones. Every generation believes it has finally understood the world. And Allah has already given this Ummah its own cave. The Qur'an. Its refuge. Its protection.
The Prophet ﷺ specifically connected the opening verses of Surah Al-Kahf with protection from Dajjal. I cannot help seeing a connection here. The young men sought protection inside a physical cave when the world around them became dangerous for their faith. And we have been given the Qur'an. We need to run towards it in times of fitnah. I imagine the world as a flooded river. The water is moving with tremendous force. We are flowing with it, sometimes without realizing where it is taking us. We desperately need something firm to hold on to. Something that does not bend with every new current. Something that keeps us rooted. QAYYIM. Without it, we become prey to the flood—moving wherever the current takes us, without a firm base or direction. And what amazes me is that Allah begins this Surah by drawing our attention to the Book itself.
6. Warning and Glad Tidings — But No Guarantee of Today's Victory
لِّيُنذِرَ بَأْسًا شَدِيدًا مِّن لَّدُنْهُ وَيُبَشِّرَ الْمُؤْمِنِينَ الَّذِينَ يَعْمَلُونَ الصَّالِحَاتِ أَنَّ لَهُمْ أَجْرًا حَسَنًا مَّاكِثِينَ فِيهِ أَبَدًا
Allah warns of Ba's Shadeed.
The expression makes me think about the destruction and wars unfolding around the world. War after war. One conflict has not ended before another begins. The warnings about great conflicts near the end of time, including Malhamah al-Kubra, also come to mind, although this particular ayah does not explicitly identify those events. Looking at the world, without claiming to know exactly where we stand in the unfolding of the final events, I cannot ignore how vulnerable humanity has become. And then Allah says to give glad tidings. But what are those glad tidings? When we think of struggle, oppression, and war, we expect glad tidings to mean victory. Winning the war. Defeating the oppressor. Seeing justice established. But Allah shifts our hearts towards the Hereafter.
مَّاكِثِينَ فِيهِ أَبَدًا
As if there is no guarantee of today's victory. We may struggle throughout our lives and never witness the outcome. We may not see the oppressor defeated. We may not see the fruits of our efforts. But Allah promises an everlasting reward to those who believe and do righteous deeds. What a shift in perspective!
The success of a believer cannot be measured only through the results visible in this world. The Hereafter is also part of reality. And if we forget that, we may misunderstand both success and failure.
7. The Prophet's Grief and the Reality of This World
فَلَعَلَّكَ بَاخِعٌ نَّفْسَكَ عَلَىٰ آثَارِهِمْ إِن لَّمْ يُؤْمِنُوا بِهَـٰذَا الْحَدِيثِ أَسَفًا
Allah addresses the grief of the Prophet ﷺ over those who refuse to believe. This makes me reflect upon the rejection of religion in the modern world. What began in parts of European history as a struggle against oppressive religious institutions eventually contributed, through many developments, to an intellectual environment where religion itself could be regarded as unnecessary.
I cannot say that this ayah specifically predicts postmodernism or that the Prophet ﷺ was anticipating those historical developments. But the grief over people turning away from revelation makes me think of that continuing human experience. Then Allah immediately speaks about the beauty of the earth.
إِنَّا جَعَلْنَا مَا عَلَى الْأَرْضِ زِينَةً لَّهَا لِنَبْلُوَهُمْ أَيُّهُمْ أَحْسَنُ عَمَلًا
Everything on earth has been beautified. But why?
لِنَبْلُوَهُمْ أَيُّهُمْ أَحْسَنُ عَمَلًا
To test who is best in deeds. And then:
وَإِنَّا لَجَاعِلُونَ مَا عَلَيْهَا صَعِيدًا جُرُزًا
All this beauty will eventually become barren ground. The very world that consumes our attention, our ambitions, our lives—everything we are competing to possess—will not remain forever. And we are so deeply absorbed in it that we often forget this reality.
8. The Same Lesson Returning Throughout the Surah
What amazes me is how this relationship between material and spiritual reality keeps appearing throughout Surah Al-Kahf.
Ashab Al-Kahf — No Power, but Faith
The young men have no worldly power. No resources sufficient to confront the authority of their society. But they have belief in Allah and the unseen. They turn towards Allah and seek protection.
يَنشُرْ لَكُمْ رَبُّكُم مِّن رَّحْمَتِهِ
And Allah makes a cave their protection. When we have no power, no resources, and no visible way out, Allah can create means of protection beyond anything we imagined.
The Man of the Two Gardens — Power and Wealth Without the Right Perspective
Here is a person who possesses everything materially. Gardens, wealth, resources, and prosperity. And he considers these sufficient for his success.
مَا أَظُنُّ أَن تَبِيدَ هَـٰذِهِ أَبَدًا
He cannot imagine losing what he possesses. But everything is destroyed. What a lesson about the impermanence of material prosperity. Wealth itself is not the problem. The problem is when it becomes our entire understanding of security and success.
Musa and Khidr — Knowledge Beyond What We Can Observe
Then comes Musa (AS) and Khidr. Every event that unfolds before Musa has an outward appearance. But there is another dimension of knowledge behind those events, granted specifically by Allah to Khidr.
The damaged boat, the boy, and the repaired wall—all have explanations that Musa could not have known merely from what he observed. How limited is our knowledge! We may know the immediate event, but not its wider consequences. We may understand what happened, but not why Allah allowed it within His larger plan. This is not knowledge ordinary human beings can claim for themselves. Nor does it mean we can justify wrongdoing by imagining hidden wisdom.
But it teaches humility before Allah's knowledge. Allah is the Planner of the entire universe—not merely of one person or one event. His knowledge encompasses generations, consequences, and realities beyond our access.
Dhul-Qarnayn — Power With the Right Mindset
And finally, Dhul-Qarnayn. He had authority. He had power. He had resources. He had the means to act. But what made him different from the man of the gardens? His understanding of what he possesses.
مَا مَكَّنِّي فِيهِ رَبِّي خَيْرٌ
هَـٰذَا رَحْمَةٌ مِّن رَّبِّي
Everything is the Ata of his Rabb. Not merely the result of his own capabilities. He uses his material resources, organizes work, and exercises authority. But he does not forget their source. And that changes how he uses power. This is the lesson we desperately need in today's world. Not to reject science, technology, development, or material resources. But to recognize that they are not the whole of reality, nor do they make humanity independent of Allah.
My Personal Connection with Al Kahf
Surah Al-Kahf has always been especially close to my heart. And the more I reflect upon it, the more I feel that humanity is losing its ability to see reality as a whole. We are so occupied with this world that the Hereafter is slowly disappearing from our decisions. We are so impressed by human knowledge that we forget the limits of that knowledge. We are so impressed by power that we forget Who granted it. We consider ourselves free, while our thoughts, desires, and choices are increasingly shaped by influences we do not fully recognize. We know so much, yet perhaps understand so little. And amidst all these fitan, Allah calls us towards His Book.
وَلَمْ يَجْعَل لَّهُ عِوَجًا ۜ قَيِّمًا
The world will continue moving. Humanity may continue shifting from one extreme to another.
But we have been given something to hold on to. Not merely to recite, but to understand. Not merely to seek confirmation of our thoughts, but to allow our thoughts to be corrected. The Qur'an does not ask us to stop seeing this world. It teaches us not to forget the other side of reality.
Dunya along with Akhirah. Material means alongside belief in Allah. Knowledge alongside humility. Power alongside accountability.
And perhaps that is what we need most in this world of fitan.
12-Nov-2026